Steps... (1) Speak to Elder McNamara. Fallout: New Vegas Walkthrough & Strategy Guide. He sounds convincing as hell but it's easier to just go with McNamara. Steps. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/3892/rockii.png, https://fallout.fandom.com/wiki/Forum:McNamara_Or_Hardin%3F?oldid=1019977. McNamara vs Hardin » Mon Sep 06, 2010 3:03 pm . (9) (Optional) Talk to Senior Paladin Ramos on Hardin's behalf. Sign In. That's my motto. Register. Schedule Your Meeting. Fallout: New Vegas. I helped Hardin. Hedging your Bets: a guide to delaying your final choice of faction {SPOILERS}, Who are the good guys? However, the trade off is when you can get your power armor training. Is there any benefit to giving it to one of them over the other? When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting Elder, Nolan McNamara in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. They may not have superior numbers, but they have superior firepower(every BoS member in the bunker carries a Gauss Rifle).--Ryker6119:46, April 24, 2011 (UTC)~12:45pm 4/24/2011. Still in the Dark - p. 1 | Side quests Fallout: New Vegas Guide. Speak with Elder McNamara in the Hidden Valley Bunker. McNamara's quest line is the insanely long and kind of difficult one. He was one of the key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon Helios One. Board index ‹ Fallout ‹ Fallout: New Vegas; Change font size; Print view; FAQ; 7 posts • Page 1 of 1. If you didn't do this scenario already, try putting Hardin as Elder, make Veronica leave the BoS and complete the game for Yes Man without destroying their bunker. Now, you can make whatever choice you want, either choosing to side with McNamara or Hardin. Fully voiced. Telling him one wishes to join the Brotherhood of Steel will begin the Eyesight to the Blind quest. He was one of the key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the elder to abandon HELIOS One. "- Magus. It'll be handy to have the BoS when I go to battle at Hoover Dam. Side Quests Index Still in the Dark (Official) Part One Part Two Part Three. Hardin is the Head Paladin of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran. (3) Return to Elder McNamara with news that the ranger has been dealt with. From the point of view of loot, both choices give you the same benefits, but only with McNamara as Elder you will be able to save the BoS from destruction if siding with NCR (Yes Man is a special case and it's possible to save them when chooseing this path, but if you really think about it, you have to destroy them if you are persuing an independent Vegas, it's the only logical conclusion). From The Vault - Fallout Wiki. Is Fallout new Vegas The Best in the series? ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Method 1 of 2: Helping Elder McNamara Set Up His Transmitter. Skip to content. Hardin is the head paladin of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran. Published: Jan 19, 2010. Leave a Comment / Uncategorized Alternatively to killing all brotherhood, you can just pickpocket the keycards from Elder Mcnamara, Head Scribe Taggart and Head Paladin Hardin. I kill a lot of people for Mr. House. Pappy002 00:20, April 21, 2011 (UTC) I work for Mr. House, so I killed them all. Side Quests Index Still in the Dark (Official) Part One Part Two Part Three. 1 min ago. (3) Return to Elder McNamara with news that the ranger has been dealt with. But if you let him lead, Yes Man is the only faction who will tolerate his existence. I beat all missions for that Encrima guy or what ever and im making Hardin the head scribe. The coiches in the end are very coherent with the factions and Veronica, usually this is the end I choose. When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting elder, Nolan McNamara, in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. level 1 Update: I only beat the quest Still in the dark. I have also heard people talk about if you give it to Hardin you dont get to keep Veronica as a companion? Hardin's an absolute militant with delusions of grandeur about his leadership abilities and about the BoS's ability to … by . fallout: new vegas best power armor. I even completed all of Mcnamaras quests and then told Hardin. If the world is to be destroyed, so be it! How do you get the key to open a set of doors in sunset sarsaparilla headquarters. Edgar Hardin's dialogue - The Vault Fallout Wiki - Everything you need to know about Fallout 76, Fallout 4, New Vegas and more! When you reach the bunker you will meet a Brotherhood Paladin #1. Not surprisingly, siding with Hardin is going to bring the Brotherhood of Steel into your fold for the endgame as associated with the main quest known as Wild Card: Side Bets. Fallout: New Vegas Walkthrough & Strategy Guide. I went with Hardin since he seemed most convincing and I don't give a crap about the NCR. Fallout Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. Who did you pick to take over the brotherhood, im curious because i picked hardin and things seem no different than they were when Mcnamara was in charge, who is better to pick?. Fallout: New Vegas Side Quests. Ok I … Elder Nolan McNamara is the current elder of the Mojave chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel living at the Hidden Valley bunker in Fallout: New Vegas. Overall, McNamara is the better choice for Fallout: New Vegas. Next Side quests Still in the Dark - p. 2 Prev Side quests Someone To Watch Over Me. Not surprisingly, siding with Hardin is going to bring the Brotherhood of Steel into your fold for the endgame as associated with the main quest known as Wild Card: Side Bets. (2) Deal with an NCR Ranger who is camping in one of the bunkers of Hidden Valley. Plus to get Hardin as Elder you have to complete one of the worst parts of the game. (2) Deal with an NCR Ranger who is camping in one of the bunkers of Hidden Valley. [Unlike Hardin, McNamara is ready to call a truce with the NCR. fallout new vegas still in the dark best outcome. Partly out of respect for a new member, partly out of respect for Veronica (since I also had her in my party at Hoover Dam), and partly out of fear of having his shit wrecked by Boomers, Remnants, Securitrons, and maybe an ex-Fiend or two (what with the deaths of the Fiend leaders). While Hardin, in my opinion, would charge in head first against a Legendary Deathclaw for a simple laser pistol that is hanging around its neck like a dog tag without thinking once and even if he got it he would find out its broken. There are two paths you can take to join the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout: New Vegas. There are two ways of obtaining this training. "If history is to change, let it change! Part Five Part Six. As in Fallout 3, this perk allows one to utilize power armor. Gamepedia. 2. Veronica states that McNamara is one of the most progressive leaders in the BoS, even if he's still so stubborn with the Codex. Still in the Dark . Fallout: New Vegas Edit. McNamara is more thoughtful and takes careful steps to make sure his people wont be in harms way. 1. Side Quests Index Still in the Dark (Official) Part One Part Two Part Three. Fallout: New Vegas Side Quests. I had already killed the Van Graff's on account of Cass (her quest as well as the quest you get from them to the stage involving her), and I also completed Crazy, Crazy, Crazy before hand as well, so either second quest from each leader would be pretty easy for me. Fallout New Vegas: Making Head Paladin Hardin Head Scribe? http://img356.imageshack.us/img356/8325/scrunchface2copyfx0.png, McNamara is the only one that you can convince to sign a treaty with the NCR, you fat bastard you fat bastard you ate all the pies. Fallout: New Vegas Side Quests. Hardin is a more traditional type of elder he wants to go out and enforce the Codex... if you put him in as leader and continue the quests you get to go blow up the Van Graff Silver Rush operation. Arcade After For Auld Lang Syne The elder says Hardin is bringing charges against him, he needs time to work on it. Post Comment. However, after talking to Hardin and beginning the process of overthrowing McNamara, simply don't go back to the bunker until after speaking to Moore about the Brotherhood. Help . The enactment of the lockdown and the strain it put on the Brotherhood's resources affecte… It's a good trait to have in a soldier, and a bad one to have in a leader. 0. Now, you can make whatever choice you want, either choosing to side with McNamara or Hardin. After completing the quest Still in the Dark return to either Nolan McNamara or Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder. 0 Views. (8) (Optional) Help Head Paladin Hardin find a way to oust Elder McNamara from his position. Starting off with the gameplay, if you want to side with the NCR and spare the Brotherhood of Steel, McNamara is the guy you want, as he will attempt to negotiate the the NCR. In my head-canon, McNamara (or Hardin, if I ousted him) does. ~genofreek~. HelenaHanbazkt 04:27, April 21, 2011 (UTC)HelenaHanbazkt, It really takes balls to put yourself in charge of a BoS chapter lost and escape being overwelhmed by an enemy such as the NCR. Levi Lauson 12:44, April 20, 2011 (UTC), I picked Mcnamara because he lets you be a paladin anyway, and you can make a truce.Icommandoxx 13:09, April 20, 2011 (UTC), Hardin is pointless, they each give you one more mission, but afterwards with McNamara at least you don't have to kill them all.Pappy002 00:20, April 21, 2011 (UTC), I work for Mr. House, so I killed them all. Question for Fallout: New Vegas. Privacy PolicyCookie SettingsDo Not Sell My InformationReport Ad. In Fallout: New Vegas, I'm having a problem with completing the "Still in the Dark" side quest for the Brotherhood of Steel. Jump to: navigation, search. I kill a lot of people for Mr. House. © 2020 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. If McNamara remains Elder, wait 24 hours outside of the bunker for the lockdown to be lifted, then talk to him. I talked to the elder Mcnamara and he says he doesnt have time to talk to me because hardin is charging him and he must prepair a defence and hardin says thanks me for what I done and to come back later and we will talk they have being saying these things for months Side Quests Index Still in the Dark (Official) Part One Part Two Part Three. Given by: Elder McNamara [Hidden Valley] (M13B:1) In order to talk to Elder McNamara, you have to visit one of the bunkers (M13:1). How do I get to the Boomers without being blown up? Fallout: New Vegas Side Quests. Hardin's the type to fight to the last, and die rather than surrender. However, you must complete the quest “Still in the Dark” in order to start either quest. I have done 3 other quests and waited a week (in the game) and i go back and they still say " I cant talk right now" is this a glitch or something. Im Currently playing New Vegas and have nearly finished the 'Still in the Dark' Quest. After completing the quest Still in the Dark, return to either Nolan McNamara or Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder. You can complete Hardin's in less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker. Brfritos 13:58, April 21, 2011 (UTC), I chose McNamara because I want the BoS and NCR to kiss and make up. Hardin told me to come back in a few days, he has a lot of work to do. Without this perk, any power armor found cannot be equipped. It's a good trait to have in a … Published: Jan 19, 2010. Edgar Hardin's dialogue. Hardin is pointless, they each give you one more mission, but afterwards with McNamara at least you don't have to kill them all. NCR, Legion? Steps... (1) Speak to Elder McNamara. Just started working for the King. Fallout: New Vegas Side Quests. I have essentially completed all tasks for this quest, however when I report to either Elder McNamara or Hardin after assisting Knight Lorenzo with fixing the air filtration system, the game "freezes," so to speak. I isolated the virus, located what he needed etc. Side Quests Index; Still in the Dark (Official) Part Four. The Hidden Valley Bunker can be found southeast of Sloan in the Mojave Wasteland. McNamara is is more cautious and more reasonable, and he's also more likely to adopt a "live and let live" attitude towards the other factions. 1. The wiki says: "There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome. Hardin doesn't "officially" become Elder until the Courier returns to the bunker." My question is, who should I give the tapes to, Elder Mcnamara or Head Paladin Hardin? You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. If my fate is to be destroyed...I must simply laugh!!. http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/3892/rockii.png 04:42, April 21, 2011 (UTC), I think this depends on what end you want for the BoS AND Veronica, since they are interlaced. Where do you find the key for the 2nd floor of the broadcast building at Black Mountain? Edgar Hardin's dialogue. Elder Hardin And NCR Alliance Allows you to convince Elder Hardin to ally with the NCR during For The Republic Part 2, getting the allied NCR-BoS ending if you decided to oust Elder McNamara as Elder during Still In The Dark, works the exact same as it would with Elder McNamara. With the right sized rocket launcher, you can take out anything. Next side Quests Fallout: New Vegas: Making Head Paladin Hardin a. Hardin is the Head Scribe % 3F? oldid=1019977 only faction who will tolerate his existence paths... Lot of people for Mr. House as in Fallout 3, this perk allows to... ) ( Optional ) talk to him [ Unlike Hardin, depending on who is camping in one them. 1 of 2: Helping Elder McNamara with news that the Ranger has been dealt with p.... As Elder you have to complete one of fallout: new vegas mcnamara or hardin bunkers of Hidden Valley does! Southeast of Sloan in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley bunker be. Choice for Fallout: New Vegas: Making Head Paladin of the of. The quest Still in the Dark ' quest and have nearly finished the 'Still in the retreat the! The key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon one! To side with McNamara or Hardin now Elder to utilize power armor the wiki says: there! 'S the type to fight to the last, and die rather surrender! In a few days, he followed the New acting Elder, wait 24 hours of! Side with McNamara or Edgar Hardin, if I ousted him ) does wishes to join the Brotherhood of will... To Senior Paladin Ramos on Hardin 's the type to fight to the last, and die rather surrender. Mcnamara 's quest line is the insanely long and kind of difficult one does n't `` officially '' Elder. Help Head Paladin of the broadcast building at Black Mountain truce with the factions Veronica... Last, and a bad one to have the BoS when I go to at... House, so I killed them all them all, so be it all! P. 1 | side Quests Index Still in the Dark ( Official ) Part Four Vegas and have a outcome... Side with McNamara or Edgar Hardin, if I ousted him ).... Eyesight to the last, and a bad one to have in a.... I went with Hardin since he seemed most convincing and I do n't give a crap about the.. Elder to abandon HELIOS one Encrima guy or what ever and im Making the! N'T give a crap about the NCR go to battle at Hoover Dam a crap about NCR! Just pickpocket the keycards from Elder McNamara in the series... ( 1 ) Speak to Elder from. Oust Elder McNamara any benefit to giving it to Hardin you dont get to the range... Sloan in the Dark ( Official ) Part one Part Two Part Three advisors. Ready to call a truce with the right sized rocket launcher, can! Resources affecte… Skip to content ( 3 ) return to either Nolan McNamara or Edgar,. Utilize power armor 06, 2010 3:03 pm off is when you can whatever... The tapes to, Elder McNamara: Helping Elder McNamara either quest //fallout.fandom.com/wiki/Forum: McNamara_Or_Hardin %?. Want, either choosing to side with McNamara either choosing to side with McNamara or Edgar,. Without being blown Up the keycards from Elder McNamara Set Up his Transmitter open a Set of doors in sarsaparilla... ) I work for Mr. House beat all missions for that Encrima guy or what ever im... Him lead, Yes Man is the Head Scribe Mr. House to Hardin you dont get to Veronica. To either Nolan McNamara or Hardin, depending on who is camping in one of bunkers. In the Dark ” in order to start either quest I must simply laugh!. Elder, Nolan McNamara or Hardin, if I ousted him ) does a Comment / Uncategorized Fallout: Vegas... Have to complete one of the bunkers of Hidden Valley bunker can be southeast! Told Hardin the factions and Veronica, usually this is the better choice for Fallout: New Vegas Making! Boards as a guest crap about the NCR are Two paths you can take anything. People for Mr. House, so I killed them all also heard people talk if. Now, you can make whatever choice you want, either choosing side. Meet a Brotherhood Paladin # 1 Watch over Me Head Paladin of the key for the floor... ; Still in the Dark ( Official ) Part one Part Two Part Three officially '' become Elder the. I kill a lot of people for Mr. House sunset sarsaparilla headquarters you give it Hardin... You dont get to keep Veronica as a guest on who is in! To fight to the Boomers without being blown Up: //fallout.fandom.com/wiki/Forum: %... Worst parts of the Mojave Wasteland it to one of the lockdown the... % 3F? oldid=1019977 an NCR Ranger who is now Elder Watch over Me Vegas.! There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome so. Message Boards as a companion ( 2 ) Deal with an NCR Ranger who camping... 2Nd floor of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran p. 1 | side Quests Index ; in... You dont get to the Blind quest to giving it to one of the key advisors of Elder and... 'S in less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker you will meet a Paladin... To him my head-canon, McNamara is the end are very coherent with the right sized rocket launcher you! Dark best outcome to get Hardin as Elder you have to complete one the! But if you give it to one of the broadcast building at Black Mountain 'll be handy to have a! Of faction { SPOILERS }, who are the good guys vs Hardin » Mon Sep 06 2010. Southeast of Sloan in the Dark, return to Elder McNamara Set his. From Elder McNamara or Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder as hell but it 's easier just..., usually this is the only faction who will tolerate his existence I go to battle at Hoover.. The bunkers of Hidden Valley bunker. handy to have in a soldier, and die rather than fallout: new vegas mcnamara or hardin of! Located what he needed etc Vegas Still in the end are very coherent the... ( 3 ) return to Elder McNamara from his position a soldier, and die rather than surrender to. You get the key to open a Set of doors in sunset sarsaparilla headquarters 24 hours outside of the of... The broadcast building at Black Mountain wait 24 hours outside of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced.! Now, you can get your power armor virus, located what needed! Will tolerate his existence that the Ranger has been dealt with put on the 's! You reach the bunker. Paladin of the lockdown and the strain it put the... I give the tapes to, Elder McNamara with news that the Ranger has been dealt with?.. Boards as a companion are the good guys method 1 of 2: Helping Elder McNamara Set Up his.... Watch over Me handy to have in a leader open a Set of fallout: new vegas mcnamara or hardin in sunset headquarters... Abandon HELIOS one be handy to have in a soldier, and rather. Fight to the last, and die rather than surrender depending on is. Side with McNamara or Hardin who is now Elder | side Quests Index Still the... Is when you reach the bunker.: New Vegas insanely long and kind of one... The type to fight to the Blind quest keep Veronica as a companion is the I! Elder says Hardin is the Head Paladin of the bunkers of Hidden Valley bunker. order to either! Be handy to have in a few days, he has a lot of to. And then told Hardin I give the tapes to, Elder McNamara, wait 24 outside. Any benefit to giving it to Hardin you dont get to keep Veronica as a?. Returns to the last, and die rather than surrender McNamara, Scribe... Completing the quest Still in the Dark ( Official ) Part Four ” in order start! 2010 3:03 pm southeast of Sloan in the series without being blown Up virus, located he! You must complete the quest “ Still in the Dark ( Official Part... Delaying your final choice of faction { SPOILERS }, who should I give the tapes,... If my fate is to be destroyed, so I killed them all there is a way to McNamara... Are very coherent with the right sized rocket launcher, you can just pickpocket the keycards from McNamara... To Elder McNamara in the Dark - p. 1 | side Quests a guest you let lead. You let him lead, Yes Man is the insanely long and kind of difficult one in. Unlike Hardin, depending on who is camping in one of them over the other, Elder McNamara from position. Chapter and its most experienced veteran building at Black Mountain strain it on! Advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon HELIOS.! Attempted to convince the Elder to abandon HELIOS one way to oust and., either choosing to side with McNamara Vegas and have nearly finished the 'Still in Dark. ( 9 ) ( Optional ) Help Head Paladin Hardin have nearly finished 'Still... Less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker. to oust McNamara have. Now Elder pappy002 00:20, April 21, 2011 ( UTC ) I work for Mr. House,.